Wednesday, November 10, 2010
Barttleby the Scrivener
This story is told completely by the point of view of the narrator. This limits the readers' knowledge because we don't know what any of the other characters are thinking or why they do what they do. My favorite part of this story was the names. Turkey, Nippers, and Ginger nut. Adorable. I really wish that I could find out what Barttleby is thinking throughout this entire story. I want to know why he was so happy doing his job and then one day just "preferred not to". The narrator attempts to send him away and fire him but Barttleby never leaves. Why does he not leave? Why does he not eat? We will never know because of the point of view of the story. I don't understand why the narrator identifies and relates with Barttleby so much. He gives him money and visits him in prison. Also, he pays the cook to feed him. The narrator is selfless in trying to help Barttleby but in the end, he killed himself.
Hunters in the Snow by Tobias Wolff
Tub is a character that the readers are meant to feel sorry for. He is teased by his friends his whole life. When they go on the hunting trip, Tub is left way behind the others. He simply cannot keep up. I felt really bad for Tub when I read the part about how he kept catching up and then falling back from his friends. It's sad to see his character struggling so much. His friends treat him horribly, too. This story later unfolds to the characters spilling their darkest secrets. Tub tells about his problem with eating and says that it has nothing to do with his glands. Frank then confides about the affair he is having with the babysitter. This secret was really weird. He is married and has children and he is considering leaving all of that for a babysitter. Really creepy. Speaking of creepy, the ending. Kenny keeps chanting that they are going to the hospital and the story responds that they are actually not. They had taken a wrong turn somewhere. It makes the reader ponder all the possibilities that could happen to the characters as a result of that wrong turn.
Everyday Use by Alice Walker
I really liked this story because i could relate to it. Me and my sister are very close in age and we often fight over belongings just like Dee and Maggie. I see myself sometimes playing Dee, selfish and confident, and I also see myself be Maggie, quiet and generous. The author sets Maggie up to be a character that you immediately feel sorry for. She is a burn victim, she lives at home, and she isn't very intelligent. Dee got all the "goods" of the family. Her mother raised enough money to send her off to college. She comes back with a husband and a fancy dress. Dee clearly holds herself over her family. She takes from Maggie the quilt that was already said to be Maggie's wedding gift. Also, Dee makes sure that she doesn't get the house in any of the pictures. We see that Dee had changed from the time she went off to college by the time she came back by Maggie's reaction. She is shocked by the transformation her sister has gone through. Also, Dee rejects the nickname her mother had called her her whole life.
Wednesday, November 3, 2010
Surprise Endings
Usually I love books with surprise endings because I am blown away by the ending that I couldn't guess. In this story, I thought the surprise ending was ridiculously obvious. The book was called "How I Met My Husband" and there were only two men in the whole story. One of them was a sleeze bag with a fiancée. My guess was that it was the mailman as soon as he came into the story. In my opinion, the ending of the story could have been taken out completely and they story would have lost no meaning at all. I know that they would have probably had to change the title but to me, the surprise ending seemed to summed up so it was less believable. If they would have dragged it out and gave more detail it would have made the story more romantic and more enjoyable.
How I Met My Husband
The whole book I knew that Chris was sleeze. He creeped me out when he watched her through the window and then told her she was beautiful. He had already been in the army and she was only 15. He must have been signifigantly older than her. Also, he had a fiance. There was a lot of dramatic irony in this story. One example is when she admits to being intimate with Chris and is bawling to all the ladies. She has no idea what it means to be intimate. After Chris and Edie are done being "intimate", he jumps off the cot and splashes water on both him and her. I think this is symbolism for him cleansing off the wrong doing that he had just done. The top of page 145 was confusing to me because Chris' fiance says that in order to prove that Edie had or had not been intimate with Chris, she was going to "examine" her. She says later that she had no idea at the time of what she had been saved from doing. Was she really going to check? That is very strange.
Interpreter of Maladies
When I first started reading the book, I didn't think the taxi driver was being that creepy. Then, I realized that he was 20 years older than Mrs. Das. I noticed some foreshadowing when Mr. Kapasi notices the difference in the skin color of his "son". It shows how his wife is unfaithful and he has no idea that the kid isn't really his son. I think this unfaithfulness is a result of their arranged marriage. I don't understand why his wife is so cold to the younger daughter. She doesn't hold her hand or paint her nails when she asks. Instead, she shakes her off and talks to her like she's an annoyance. I saw some similarities between this story and "How I Met My Husband". They both involve letters and they also both have an unrealistic idea of love. The idea of "sweeping their lover off their feet and living happily ever after". I thought it was odd how the author emphasized the dress of Mrs. Das. She showed a lot of skin and her "largely bare legs" (pg. 147) I didn't understand the purpose of her dress or why they would mention this.
A Rose For Emily
All of the flashbacks in this story confuse me. I can't tell what the chronological order of events are and where each book begins and leaves off. Book II is the most confusing. It begins 30 years before her funeral, 2 years after her father dies, and 1 year after Homer goes missing. After reading over this section several times, I finally started to understand what was happening first. Another thing I didn't really understand was the tax situation. She didn't have to pay her taxes for a long period of time. It seemed like the mayor or whatever it was felt bad for her because of the loss of her husband and her father so he didn't make her pay them. Then, all of a sudden, she had to pay them again. We see this on page 282 and it explains it in more detail, that I don't understand. Also I didn't think that the title of this story fit the tone of it at all. A Rose For Emily? how about, "Emily; A Girl Who Naps With Dead Bodies". That would have been more appropriate. I don't understand why the author decided to name this story so positive.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)