Thursday, December 2, 2010
The Lottery
The first thing that struck me as weird was the little boys collecting stones at the beginning of the story. I didn't notice until after I read the story that this was foreshadowing. "they smiled more than they laughed", yes phrase is also eerie because it shows how the men of the town are all preoccupied with other things on their mind. They are worried about something. Old Man Warner encouraged them to go through with the lottery. Nobody outright rejected it. They all just went through the motions, almost like robots. It stuck out to me towards the end when Mrs. Hutchinson was chosen, her family was not upset. In fact, her son was given some rocks to assist the others in murdering his mom. Also, when she was chosen, she exclaimed how unfair it was because her daughters were not involved in the draw. It was disturbing how unfeeling the people are in this story.
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Analysis of "Shoeless Joe Jackson Comes to Iowa"

Plot:
The story is sprinkled with the narrator looking back on the life of Joe Jackson as it relates to him. It is also flashbacks of how he came to be a young Iowa farmer. Throughout the story, it alternates between flashbacks and present day. The rising action of this story is building the field for Shoeless Joe. It is the anticipation and waiting of the narrator. The voices he hears reassure him that his dream will eventually come true; "if you build it, he will come." The story then continues to the climax. His wife discovers a man on the lawn, the man, of course, is Shoeless Joe Jackson. The story progresses to the falling action of the narrator watching the game. He is thrilled that his hard work is paying off. Finally, the narrator agrees to expand the field for other players to come."If you were to finish the infield, why, old Chick Gandil could play first base, and we'd have the Swede at shortstop and Buck Weaver at third." (521) This resolution shows how the narrators dream has come true.
Point of View:
The point of view of this story comes from a middle aged farmer who raises his family in Iowa. He has grown up with baseball his entire life. The audience is never given a name of the man telling the story. The narrator has the point of view of a handy man. His "do it yourself" attitude is apparent. " A three hour lecture or a five-hundred-page guidebook could not have given me clearer directions: dimensions of ballparks jumped over and around me like fleas, cost figures for light standards and floodlights whirled around my head like the moths that dusted against the porch light above me." (511) He works hard to maintain his farm, builds a gigantic baseball field, and doesn't rest until it is perfect. This hardworking attitude eventually rewards him.
Characterization:
The narrator is described through indirect characterization. He is described when he elaborates on his love of baseball, his family, and his land. "I count the loves in my life: Annie, Karin, Iowa, and Baseball. The great god Baseball." He puts his family before his land and baseball, but he goes on to compare baseball with a god. The narrator is a man with dreams. We see this also through indirect characterization as he dedicates his money and time to build a baseball field on his own. The narrators wife, Annie, is described directly. "...that slip of a girl with hair the color of cayenne pepper and at least a million freckles on her face and arms, that girl who lives in blue jeans and T-shirts and at twenty-four could pass for sixteen." She is then described as a great mother and wife. This direct characterization shows that the story is focused on figuring out the narrator, and not so much the wife or the daughter.
Setting:
The story takes place on an farm in Iowa around the year 1970. It takes place many years after Shoeless Joe Jackson was suspended from baseball and had passed away. I think that an argument can be made that this story could also take place in heaven. The dreams of the narrator and Shoeless Joe both come true. The narrator builds a beautiful baseball field for his idol and Shoeless Joe returns to his beloved game. They are both at peace and appreciative of each other. "'God what an outfield,' he says. 'What a left field.' He looks up at me and I look down at him. 'This must be heaven,' he says.""I think you're right, Joe," I say, but softly enough not to disturb his concentration." (522) They are both at such peace with they're surroundings.
Theme:
The theme of this story is that if you work hard for your dream, it will come true. The motif of "if you build it, he will come", is a message that is repeated over and over again in the narrators head. As a result, he puts a tremendous amount of effort into building the baseball field that will bring in his ultimate goal. He makes sure everything is perfect for his arrival, and one night, his dream comes true. "'How does it play?' I holler down. 'The ball bounces true,' he replies. 'I know.' I am smiling with pride and my heart thumps mightily against my ribs." It can be inferred that narrator is not a many of money or possessions and that, in the end, is the reason he works so hard for the simple things.
Wednesday, November 17, 2010
Once Upon a Time
I think this story is really sad. The ending when the little boy dies completely ruined it for me. The family is so concerned about protecting their house from the outside world. They put so many alarms on, make their wall higher, and put a contraption of blades around the house. It seems that they are over protective and they should have just lived without being in fear. In the end, their paranoidity (if thats a word) killed there son. They could protect the house from the outside world but they could not protect the family from the house. I like how this story is a frame story. The author starts off talking about writing a childrens story. Then she gets sidetracked by the noises she hears in the house. Finally, she tells herself a story so that she can get her mind off the noises and go to sleep. This story would have made me even more scared.
A Worn Path
Today my group and I debated on whether or not the detail of the grandson being alive or dead was important to the general message of the story. I think it is very important. If the grandson is alive, then the story is about a sweet old grandmother who takes care of her grandson. If he is dead, then the story is about a grandmother who cannot let go of her grandson's death. It's like a Rose for Emily. Tragic and sad. This detail, to me, makes a huge difference in the story. However, a student was given the chance to ask the author if the grandson was dead or alive. The author responded, "Phoenix is alive". This shows that the author made this story about the grandmother and not about the grandson. The detail does not change how caring the grandmother is. I found it ironic when the hunter says he would give her a dime if he had any money. Phoenix has all his money (:
Eveline
I really wanted her to leave with her lover. I felt bad for Eveline because her life seemed very repetitive and sad. She is obviously afraid of taking risks. She is so close to moving on but hesitates and decides against it. She is extremely indecisive. She goes back to live in her status quo life. I think that the author is making a generalization about all of Dublin and that they all just live by the status quo. My group struggled today on the meaning behind her giving her father the money she earned at work. She seemed to treat him like a bank. She would give him all her wages and then she would have to beg to get any back. She didn't like her job and she was just unhappy generally. It's sad that she didn't run away with her lover because I think that this character needs to escape from her miserable life. In truth, all she saw in him was a way out. She didn't really love him.
Miss Brill
This lady seems extremely lonely. It's pretty cool how she makes it out to be a play in her mind. I dont understand the part where she tells the man she's an actress. Sometimes I watch people, too. Especially in the airport haha. It's actually really entertaining so I don't blame her. At the end, a couple notices her staring at them. They talk about her like she's the creepy lady who watches people really sunday. She lives through other people. It very subtly mentions that she is an English teacher. This could show how she lives in a different world. She also treats her fur like its alive (personification). Also, at the end when she puts it away she says that she thought she heard crying. I think that she is really discovering her own sad and lonely emotions but rejecting them.
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
Male Bonding
In the story, Hunters in the Snow, we see a lot of testosterone. Frank, Tub, and Kenny go on a manly hunt in the great outdoors in the freezing cold. After Tub shoots Kenny, they rough him around and take their sweet old time getting him to the hospital. They are basically telling him to be a man and get over the pain. At the diner, Frank and Tub spill their darkest secrets to each other. They both tell things that they have been hiding. Through these secrets, they become closer and better friends. It's kind of adorable. They both have terrible secrets but they accept them because they are friends now. The characters Frank and Tub go through a major change in that they become close friends and admit their secrets.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)